Seville Orange Marmalade

Seville oranges: Now in season – January/February.

Bringing a blast of colour to the bleakness of winter are Seville oranges. Aromatic, with a bumpy thick skin, Seville oranges are notable for their intense bitter taste – perfect for cooking, especially marmalade. Happiness in a jar.The process of making marmalade with Seville oranges is incredibly pleasurable. It’s also slightly magical because the oranges contain high levels of pectin, a natural gelling agent which, when combined with sugar and cooled, sets to form a firm amber-coloured jelly.

If you Google how to make marmalade you will find loads of different recipes, and so it’s just a case of picking whichever one takes your fancy and having a go. And whether you like your marmalade with thick or thin-cut peel, with no peel at all, or with a glug of booze, the beauty of making your own is that you’re free to adapt it to your own exact preference.

A word of warning: you’ll need to make marmalade in two stages, so I’d advise making it when you’ve got a free weekend.

After a bit of trial and error, I found Nigel Slater’s recipe to be the best, especially as his method of scoring the oranges meant I didn’t lose any juice, the peel was easy to remove, and could easily be cut up into neat little strips. I’ve used his recipe in part with my own adaptations.

You will need
12 Seville oranges
1 lemon
1.25kg unrefined golden caster sugar 
1 or 2 muslin cooking bags.
Large cooking or preserving pan

1.) Using a small sharp kitchen knife, score four lines down each fruit from top to bottom, as if you were cutting the fruit into quarters. Let the knife cut through the peel but without piercing the fruit.
Cut each quarter of peel into fine shreds. On my first attempt I thought I’d managed to cut the shreds pretty fine but on reflection they were still a bit too chunky. It’s personal preference, of course, but I’d advise aiming to get your slices thinner than a matchstick if you can.

2.) Squeeze each of the peeled oranges and lemons into a jug, removing and reserving all the pulp and pips.

3.) Make the juice up to 4 litres with cold water, pouring it into the bowl with the shredded peel. Use more than one bowl if you need to. Tie the reserved pith, squeezed-out orange and lemon pulp and the pips in muslin bag and push into the peel and juice. Set aside in a cold place and leave overnight.

4.) The next day, tip the juice and shredded peel into a large stainless steel or enamelled pan and push the muslin bag down under the juice. Bring to the boil then lower the heat so that the liquid continues to simmer. It is ready when the peel is totally soft and translucent. One my first attempt, with really chunky peel, this took about an hour and 10.

5.) Place a small plate or saucer into the fridge to cool. Sounds strange but you’ll need it later.

5.) Once the fruit is ready, lift out the muslin bag and leave it in a bowl until it is cool enough to handle. Add the sugar to the peel and juice and turn up the heat, bringing the marmalade to a rolling boil. Squeeze as much juice as you can from the reserved muslin bag into the pan. As you squeeze you should feel that the juice coming out of the muslin is thicker than when you started. Leave at a fast boil for 15 minutes.

6.) Remove the chilled plate from the fridge,  add tablespoon of the preserve and then put it back in the fridge for a few mins. Your marmalade has reached setting point if a crinkly skin has formed on the top. Test it by dragging your finger across the surface. Test every 10 – 15 mins (some mixtures can take up to 50 mins so be patient!)

7.) Skim off any scum from the surface and then switch the pan off and leave it to settle for 15/20 mins (if you don’t then you the peel will rise to the top of your marmalade).

8.) Ladle into the sterilised pots, seal immediately and leave alone until the jars have cooled completely.

7 thoughts on “Seville Orange Marmalade”

  1. Hi Mel, thanks for dropping by and commenting on my blog – my first comment – woohoo! Such a shame you can’t get hold of Sevilles in the Netherlands. You could try with other types though, clementines etc make wonderful marmalade. 🙂 x

  2. I hadn’t thought of clementines! This year I intend to experiment with limes, and grapefruit. I am also hoping that a friend who goes to Seville every February will bring me some. I will have to bribe her with lots of dinners!

    Thanks for the clementines tip!

  3. Wonderful foodie blog, congratulations. I made marmalade for the first time this year after word got out amongst NZ food bloggers that Seville Oranges were available. Home grown in the Hawkes Bay area in North East NZ. I used a one stage method from The British Larder and it’s the best marmalade I’ve ever tasted. We have two types – one with vanilla and one just plain. My husband says the vanilla one is too girly for him but I love it and it’s perfect for eating now which is of course our summer.
    Domestic Executive

    • Thanks so much for your comments! I never thought of putting vanilla in the marmalade – it sounds like it would be lovely though. And if your hubby doesn’t like it then all the more for you! I’ll have to check out the British Larder method to the next time I make it. I love the taste of the one I made but I did have to do it over two days, so would love to find a simpler method.


Leave a Comment